Friday, 20 November 2026

The Valentine Thomas Plot of 1598.

There were many plots to end (with extreme prejudice) the reign of Elizabeth I, the Northern Rebellion (1569), the Ridolfi plot (1571), the Campion plot (1581), the Throckmorton plot (1583), the Parry plot (1585), the Babington plot (1586), the Lopez plot (1594), the Squire plot (1598), the Essex Rebellion (1601). They didn't usually end well for the plotters, but it's enough to make the best of us feel at least a little paranoid.

As Elizabeth was a protestant monarch most of the attempts were of a religious nature, lots of catholic malcontents conspiring on a bit of regime change. It didn't help that England was sandwiched between two catholic countries, France and Scotland. Spain was also very much in the mix and was keen to see the back of good Queen Bess, as demonstrated by the disastrous armada campaign of 1588. 

The country was awash with spies, fortunately Elizabeth's spymaster Sir Francis Walsingham was a dab hand at foiling their machinations, his department had many ingenious methods of extracting confessions, and many of the aforementioned plots and plotters came to a grisly end after a session with Walsingham. 

Sir Francis Walsingham

Fortunately for our subject, Valentine Thomas, the great spycatcher was dead, having passed away in 1590, however, as we shall see, the methods of gaining the "truth" had not changed.

Valentine Thomas has been described as either a servant or a soldier, he was most likely both. An Englishman supposedly in the service of the Scottish King James VI, he was exposed by a Scotsman called Robert Crawforth.

Back in the 16th century the borderland between England and Scotland was a hotbed of outlaws and reiving families, a very dangerous place indeed. To cross the border legally you would have to produce a safe conduct pass or passport if challenged. One such transgressor was Robert Crawforth, he was arrested and taken to Morpeth Castle where he told the deputy warden of the middle march of Northumberland and constable of Morpeth Castle Edward Grey a rather interesting story, a plot against the Queen of England.

An example of a "passport", this was for an Englishman going into Scotland.

The plot centered upon a man called Valentine Thomas, who also went by the names Anderson and Alderson. It appeared Thomas had gained the friendship of John Stewart, who was the gatekeeper or usher to King James VI at the palace of Holyrood. Here Thomas conspired with the King to kill the English Lord Treasurer William Cecil, raise up the English catholics in rebellion, stab the Queen to death, and put James on the English throne.

It was also alleged that Thomas had met with lairds Campbell, and MacDonald at Linlithgow Palace, one James MacDonald being a kinsman of Sorley Boy MacDonnell, a known Irish rebel and a thorn in the side of the English. King James when hearing of this meeting was allegedly heard to say "Sorley Boy", this was no threat of bringing such a notorious and successful rebel to Scotland as Sorley Boy MacDonnell had died in 1590, it was more to invoke a memory.

Holyrood Palace.

Thomas was by now a very wanted man, Grey employed Crawforth in finding Thomas and he was soon secured in Morpeth Castle, he may have already been in custody on a charge of theft. He was then sent to London's Marshalsea prison and on to the Tower Of London for further questioning. 

It was here that the aforementioned story unfolded, the tale could be very damaging to English/Scottish relations as James was intended to succeed to the English throne after Elizabeth's death. Any whiff of an assassination attempt would probably change her mind, however, it would seem that James was more concerned about the affair than Elizabeth, she thought it a little far fetched as the correspondence between them shows.

Morpeth Castle.
Elizabeth to James - 1st July 1598;

"My dear brother, suppose not that my silence hath any other root than hating to make an argument of my writing to you that should molest you or trouble me, being most desirous that no mention might once be made of so villainous an act, especially that might but in word touch a sacred person.

But now I see that so lavishly it hath been used by the author thereof, that I can refrain no longer to make you partake thereof sincerely, from the beginning to this hour, of all that hath proceeded.

And for more speed have sent charge with Bowes (William Bowes, the Queen's representative in James VI court), to utter all without fraud or guile, assuring you that few things have displeased me more since our first amities. And charge you in Gods name to believe, that I am not so viperous a nature to suppose or have thereof a thought against you, but shall make the deviser have his desert, more for that than ought else.

Referring myself to the true trust of this gentleman, to whom I beseech you give full assistance in all he shall assure you on my behalf. And so God I beseech to prosper you with all his graces, as doth desire,

Your most affectionate sister."

James to Elizabeth - July or August 1598;

"Madame and dearest sister, I have none, according to my promise in my other letter, directed unto you the bearer heirof, my servant, whereof ye shall be informed, what I crave for clearing my honour anent these slanders which that base villain hath raised upon me; wherein I doubt not but your honour and love towards me will move you not to see me innocently wronged.

The particulars here of I will not trouble you with by longsome letter, but remit same to his declaration, together with sundry other things wherewith I am falsely charged, as God shall judge me. For, on my honour, I would wish that all the direct and indirect dealings that ever I had, that might concern your person or state, were in a book laid open before you, and then you would see, that no subject of England hath kept himself clearer of any guilty thought against you than I have done, ever since I was born.

I have likewise commanded him to deal with you in diverse other things, wherein I also pray you to give him a favourable ear and trust. As for this foul attempt upon the borders, whereof I lately wrote unto you, I doubt nothing of the equity of your judgement in case you be truly informed, but I know your officers on the border will make a fault to seem unto you as small and light as they can; but consider they are parties, and determine according to right.

And thus, madame and dearest sister, I recommend you to the tuition of the Almighty.

Your most loving and affectionate brother and cousin."

King James VI.

Even though Elizabeth seems to have moved on James was still unhappy with the insinuation of being mixed up in the plot, James fires off another letter to Elizabeth in early 1599;

"The ground of my request was, to be freed of that untrue as ugly, imputation and calumny, laid against me by so infamous a villain, seduced thereto by his own self love, seeking thereby the farthest of the most detestable death, or else by my malicious though undeserved haters.

Not that I want, or need it, to crave to be made clear of any such treacherous attempts, whereof indeed I ever was most clear, but that my effectual innocence might be made known, which none may in some measure be obscured by murmuring sumises flowing from this filthy spring."

He doth seem to protest too much....methinks, or most likely not. Meanwhile in the Tower of London, Valentine Thomas was trying his hand at poetry, scrawled onto a chimney breast in charcoal was this ditty;

"I shot at a fair white: And in losing of my arrow
My elbow was wrested. But I melt for grief
To lose such a game: having so fair a mark.
But if I had escaped that wrest, God knoweth without all peradventure
I had won that game: To the great comfort of England
And profit of myself."

James had it copied and he poured over it trying to find rhyme or reason, he could find neither. The legal documents on Thomas's trial were transcribed and sent to James so he could be kept up to date, it was even proposed to send Thomas to Scotland to face torture under English supervision, before being returned to London for execution.  Elizabeth signed a document stating that she did not believe there was any such plot coming from Scotland.

Valentine Thomas would remain a prisoner in the Tower for several years, after being found guilty of treason he was finally led out to be hanged, drawn and quartered. It was on the 7th June 1603 that he was taken to St. Thomas-a-Watering on the Old Kent Road, a place of public execution for religious dissenters. King James VI of Scotland would be crowned James I of England 48 days later on the 25th July.



No comments :

Post a Comment